libera/#devuan/ Thursday, 2023-06-15

ecxodhello my friends, some days ago somebody passed me a list with packages that where not yet working without systemd, but for some reason I lost it. does someone have the location?11:58
brocashelmecxod: do you mean this? https://pkgmaster.devuan.org/bannedpackages.txt12:03
ecxodthank you my fried!! exactly12:03
brocashelmnp12:03
brocashelmthese are the current packages that devuan has blacklisted, due to systemd or impossible to use without systemd12:04
ecxodexactly what I was looking for12:04
brocashelmthe rest of the packages are either merged with debian's repos (safe to use without systemd) and exclusive forks (200-300, give or take)12:05
ecxodis this a living list? are you updating it? or is it a one time tango?12:08
rrqthe list is "live"; indefinite rumba ;)12:10
rrq.. or perhaps eternal polka12:11
DashiePiehi15:12
tom-1Hello . I would appreciate any advice or help.16:03
tom-1Patch question. (DWM)16:03
tom-1Example.16:03
tom-1I open the terminal on 1 tag, in the terminal I select for example a text file and open it with -ok. After that, a text editor opens on the 5th tag, I see it, but I stay on the 1st tag. What patch do I need to install so that I move to the tag where the text editor opens?16:03
xrogaanI don't use DWM, sorry16:22
nemobrocashelm: I'm rather shocked tomcat anything is on that list ☹16:58
nemo(banned packages)16:58
nemoesp docs16:58
nemobrocashelm: hm. says tomcat9... so tomcat10 is fine?17:00
nemoit's not listed in dædalus17:00
nemohrm. speaking of dædalus... I assume even if it's not officially released, it's not far off at this point17:01
nemoI could probably start putting it on dev servers to get ready for prod17:01
hacksenwerkHi. I don't know who removed my access to the forum, but please delete my name from the database too. It is still there: https://dev1galaxy.org/profile.php?id=643517:19
nemohacksenwerk: hm. wasn't me, but yeah, when I remove a user on request from hedgewars, I always set their username to user653517:46
nemoor whatever the uid is17:46
hacksenwerknemo: Yeah anonymisation is also ok.17:47
nemowe don't get many requests like that, but I always try to get the user to agree to leaving posts in place 'cause, well, I haven't automated it, and it's such a pain to clean up.17:49
nemoand... removing 'em tears ragged holes in the history and makes everything confusing17:49
nemofortunately in your case it seems you have no posts, orrrr, the person wiping didn't care17:50
nemopedantry-wise, personally if I was you and trying to erase data links, I probably would have contacted people by private message on here ☺17:51
nemoyou know, since best to assume all public forums are recorded17:51
nemoanother issue ofc with these "after the fact" things is validating identity...  best to get all deletion parameters in writing up front while the person still controls the account17:54
hacksenwerknemo: Yes I didn't post anything. I contacted all users of the admin group of the forum here in irc via pm, but without a response.17:59
hacksenwerkIt is the last account I need to delete from my big account removing from many sites I did the last time.18:00
u53r_Hi all!20:20
debdogAhoy!20:22
golinuxIf you have a question, just ask20:22
hacksenwerku53r_: Hi20:43
u53r_One second please :)20:43
u53r_and i asked20:44
u53r__I have next situation on today: i have a thinkpad t440, but i need help with wifi driver.20:55
u53r__Exactly, i want have more or less libre os linux-based20:57
fsmithredu53r__, for wireless driver installation, you can use debian wiki for information. We use the same packages.20:57
fsmithredwiki.debian.org - which wireless hardware do you have?20:58
fsmithredand how did you install devuan? Wireless firmware packages are usually installed automatically if they are needed.20:58
u53r__I have the following questions: Devuan developers where do they usually take non-free or free drivers for wifi cards?21:00
fsmithrednot sure I understand the question. For debian bullseye and devuan chimaera and anything older than that, wireless firmware packages are in non-free. In bookworm/daedalus they are in non-free-firmware (a new section)21:01
fsmithredbrb, I need to get a power cord.21:02
u53r__Why if I choose to install only the standard utilities, then I do not have a wifi connection?21:02
n4dirbecause they are usually non-free, but that has changed a bit, not sure how exactly it changed21:03
n4dirthat is: if you can use it during installation (for debian, devuan will be similar, i assume)21:03
fsmithredu53r__, is it one of the broadcoms that can't be installed without a network connection?21:05
fsmithredwhich hardware and how did you install?21:05
u53r__I mean, this patent doesn't care that I use proprietary drivers.21:05
u53r__fsmithred: no21:07
rustyaxeCan one pass dmcrypt password on the kernel commandline? I just swapped my ssd into a new (to me) machine and for some reason, i cant get usb keyboard working in the initrd - UEFIs usb stack sees it and i can edit command line in grub, so that'd get me in the machine at least21:08
rwprustyaxe, I don't know but question is this a stock generic kernel or a custom kernel?  Has the /etc/initramfs-tools/initramfs.conf MODULES line been modified to reduce the size of the initramfs therefore missing the USB driver?21:10
rustyaxestock kernel, but if i can poke the password into kernel command line, i can ssh into the machine and sort it as needed21:10
rwpAlso I might try booting the netinst ISO in rescue-mode.  That should be able to boot.  Then use it to rebuild the initramfs with hopefully the correct USB keyboard driver and try that.21:11
u53r__Can I leave the wifi driver to work after I complete the installation by choosing to install only the standard utilities in the installer that devuan uses?21:11
rwpu53r__, You can always install anything like that later.  That's always possible.21:12
u53r__rwp, but i not know how do this?21:13
rwpYour Thinkpad T440 *I think maybe* will use the firmware-iwlwifi package firmware.  As noted that was moved from non-free to non-free-firmware section.21:13
rwpu53r__, Which installation ISO are you using?21:13
u53r__standart devuan chimera amd64 iso21:14
* rustyaxe reenables PXE boot and does this the unpleasant way...21:14
rwpBackground: For years the Debian installation ISOs (and therefore Devuan) did not include anything from non-free.  But recently by General Resolution they voted to include non-free drivers in the installation ISO.  I do not recall when this took effect, if it is in effect now or not.21:15
fsmithredrwp, yes non-free-firmware sectoion is active in bookworm/daedalus21:16
n4dirper default?21:16
rwpDoes that include the install kernel on the ISO too?21:16
fsmithredyes, debian now installs the non-free firmware by default.21:16
fsmithredthere is still a non-free section for other non-free stuff21:17
rwpThen u53r__ should have WiFi available during install.  And also the non-free-firmware section should be available too.21:17
n4dirso non-free-firmware is added per default, but non-free and contrib are not?21:17
scorpion2185[m]but you can select 100% free21:17
scorpion2185[m]right?21:17
fsmithredyeah, pretty sure you can21:17
rwpscorpion2185[m], I think the problem is that the T440 u53r__ is using requires the firmware-iwlwifi firmware blob in order to function.  Most Thinkpads need it.21:18
u53r__am I right in thinking that I can just download the package non-free-firmware via apt?21:18
fsmithredin devuan, in the past, you had to select expert install and use a network mirror21:18
fsmithredto exclude the firmware21:18
fsmithredu53r__, it should be in the iso, in /firmware21:18
rwpu53r__, Do you have a running system installed okay?  If so then yes.  "apt-get install firmware-iwlwifi" and then reboot and it should work.  View /var/log/boot or "dmesg" to look for missing firmware.21:19
fsmithredotherwise, yeah download and install with 'dpkg -i <package>21:19
rwprustyaxe, You don't have any other way to boot the installer other than PXE?  No USB boot?  No CDROM boot?  Bummer!  But rescue-mode IIRC gives the option to decrypt encrypted partitions and guides through the chroot to the system and then you should be able to rebuild the initramfs and best of all your keyboard should be working through it.21:20
u53r__the problem is that I can't use proprietary firmware for my wifi module and for Ethernet (RJ-45, I don't know for sure if there is free firmware for this) without selecting devuan enviroment installation during the installation process.21:23
u53r__and I would like to do a clean installation of my packages while using my wi-fi card.21:25
rwpThat just does not sound like it matches what I know about things.  :-(  But I know there is a remove_firmware.sh cleaner script according to the docs https://www.devuan.org/os/install to remove those politically incorrect firmwares after install if you desire.21:26
rwpAlso look through https://www.devuan.org/os/documentation/install-guides/chimaera/install-devuan for screenshots of an installation.21:27
scorpion2185[m]I didn't follow,  usb-tethering?21:27
u53r__yes21:27
scorpion2185[m]so you don't need the wifi-card21:28
rwpMy personal belief is that firmware is tightly coupled to the hardware.  If people decide they don't want the firmware then I say they have decided not to use the hardware too.  Can't use one without the other.  That's inconsistent.21:28
rwpWhere was usb tethering mentioned in anything from u53r__?  I just reviewed and I don't see anything about usb tethering but only T440 wifi.  This confuses me.21:29
u53r__that is, the choice of installing XFCE4 is necessary to get this very firmware?21:30
rwpNo.21:30
rwpI also don't think installing XFCE4 will install firmware-iwlwifi either.  Those are unrelated.21:32
n4dirit will come with a network-manager though21:32
rwpInstalling XFCE4 will pull in network-manager.  Agreed.21:32
n4dirperhaps that is his problem, after installing without GUI the lack of a gui-network-manager21:32
rwpGood observation.  Should we explore that possibility?21:33
rustyaxerwp: pxe is just fastest way to get into a working system on it as i have pxe already available n such21:33
n4dirwild thoughts: we could wait what he says to that interpretation :-)21:33
n4diri am really not sure what his real problem is, but i am not that much in wifi21:33
rwpPXE booting is awesome!  (Unfortunately I have let my local environment bit rot and I need to fix it.)21:34
rustyaxeThu Jun 15 15:32:33 2023 daemon.info dnsmasq-tftp[1]: sent /tftp/netboot.xyz.efi to 10.187.187.13121:34
u53r__It's strange, but if I choose to install only system utilities, then my Internet connection does not work even via Ethernet.21:34
rwpI have used a lot of Thinkpads and most of them have the Intel WiFi and all have required the firmware-iwlwifi firmware blobs installed.21:34
n4diru53r__: probably no entry in /etc/network/intefaces for ethernet then21:36
rwpu53r__, That is very unexpected!  I myself usually go so far as to uncheck ALL of the boxes even the "standard system utilities" (to avoid exim4 getting installed, I install postfix) and networking works and I then install what I want.21:36
n4diryou could do a quick "dchlient eth0"; or such21:36
rwpOr possibly "ifup eth0".  But definitely run "ip addr show" to see what the names of the network devices are at that time.21:37
n4dirbut if i had ethernet that is what i would choose when asked which network-card to use, right at the beginning of the installation process21:37
n4dirand then it should work after the installation process automatically21:37
rwpAgreed.  It's so much simpler and more robust to use wired ethernet for the installation.21:37
* rwp must drop afk for a while, good luck!21:38
* rustyaxe goes back to stringing up a twisted pair along the alley to his neighbor's house so we can play DOOM using dialup modems and my PBX :P21:41
u53r__10 mins wait21:41
n4dirwaiting for what?21:42
scorpion2185[m]rwp I suggested to use usb tethering, so you don't need to use the wifi card.21:43
scorpion2185[m]you connect the phone to the wifi or something and share that via usb21:43
scorpion2185[m] but I didn't follow21:43
u53r__I don't understand what the magic is, but when I reinstalled it, everything worked for me21:55
u53r__I don't like such moments21:55
n4dirOh. What an outcome. But great21:56
u53r__I can add one more note that ifconfig does not seem to output all interfaces (if they do not have a connection) when ip addr show showed me all interfaces, even wlan0.22:05
rwpu53r__, That ip shows all but ifconfig does not show all is expected for some years now due to Linux kernel internal changes that ifconfig does not know about. ip is now the standard tool. Regardless of traditionalists *wanting* to use ifconfig. Even I have converted to ip on Linux systems.22:39
gnarfaceu53r__: ifconfig -a22:40
gnarfacerwp: regardless, this isn't an example of a new feature.22:40
gnarfaceit basically ONLY matters with equal-cost multipath routing.22:41
gnarfacethere's just about nothingn in practical use cases ifconfig actually lacks22:41
rwpI'll keep using ip on Linux systems just the same. :-)22:42
gnarfaceso basically, if you're not load-balancing uploads across multiple separate physical gateways, ip gives you nothing useful other than a change in syntax and default behaviors22:42
gnarfaceit's fine for you to use whatever you want, but it's not fine to omit information like "ifconfig -a"22:43
gnarfaceit was never the default to show unconfigured devices22:43
rwpSince ip is the officially recommended and supported tool from the Linux kernel developers I might reverse that and say the same thing!22:43
rwpTraditionally I think ifconfig has always showed unconfigured devices too.  And by that I mean on HP-UX (where I spent a lot of time) and other BSD based kernels like it.22:44
gnarfacenot any time recently on linux22:45
rwpLinux has done some odd things.  Linux reverses the order of routes in the "netstat -nr" (and ip route show) output.  It's upside down!  But only for IPv4.22:45
rwpThe IPv6 listing is in the correct order.  Go figure!22:46
gnarface"ifconfig -a" is the default on openbsd, you're right about that22:46
gnarfaceit says right in the man page22:46
rwpIt's also the default on FreeBSD and NetBSD too.  So Linux is outnumbered by the numbers.22:46
gnarfaceright, but let's be honest here. you knew the user's problem was not a regression in ifconfig.22:58
gnarfacebut you allowed that to be implied on purpose, to push an agenda.22:59
gnarfacedevuan still supports ifconfig22:59
gnarfaceand so far at least, the introduction of ip hasn't broken it22:59
rwpNo.  I did NOT know what the users problem was with ifconfig.  I have not used ifconfig in a decade.  I know it is strongly recommended against and I stopped using it.23:00
rwpI learned from you just now that ifconfig does not show unconfigured interfaces.  I never knew that before a few minutes ago.23:00
rwpBecause on every other kernel it does show all interfaces.  Let's jump over to -offtopic and continue.23:01

Generated by irclog2html.py 2.17.0 by Marius Gedminas - find it at https://mg.pov.lt/irclog2html/!